Skip to content

Penpal Book Summary

by Dathan Auerbach


Dathan Auerbach


Penpal is a chilling and unsettling epistolary horror novel that unfolds through a series of interconnected online forum posts, emails, and personal accounts. The unnamed narrator pieces together fragmented memories of his childhood, gradually revealing a disturbing and sinister mystery that has haunted him for years. As he delves deeper into his past, he uncovers a web of eerie coincidences, unsettling encounters, and unexplained events that point towards a dark and terrifying truth about his childhood penpal.

Table of contents

Open Table of contents

Author & Writing Background

Dathan Auerbach is an American author known for his works in horror and suspense. ‘Penpal’ originated as a series of creepypasta stories posted online, gaining significant popularity before being compiled and published as a novel. Auerbach’s writing is characterized by its atmospheric and suspenseful tone, psychological depth, and exploration of the uncanny and disturbing.

Key Takeaways

Fragmented Narrative

The story is told through a non-linear and fragmented narrative structure, with the narrator piecing together memories and events from his past through various forms of communication, creating a sense of mystery and suspense.

Unreliable Narrator

The unnamed narrator’s perspective is unreliable due to his fragmented memories and potential psychological trauma, leaving the reader to question the accuracy and interpretation of events.

Childhood Trauma

The novel explores themes of childhood trauma and the lasting impact of disturbing experiences on the narrator’s psyche and his perception of reality.

The Uncanny and Disturbing

Auerbach masterfully creates an atmosphere of unease and dread by incorporating elements of the uncanny and the supernatural, blurring the lines between reality and imagination.

Epistolary Format

The use of an epistolary format, with emails, forum posts, and personal accounts, adds to the authenticity and immediacy of the narrative, drawing the reader into the mystery.

Psychological Horror

Penpal delves into the psychological aspects of horror, focusing on the narrator’s internal struggles, paranoia, and the gradual unraveling of his sanity as he confronts his past.

Mystery and Suspense

The novel is driven by a central mystery surrounding the narrator’s childhood penpal and the strange events that have haunted him, keeping the reader engaged and guessing until the end.

Exploration of Memory

Penpal examines the nature of memory and its unreliability, highlighting how past experiences can be distorted, fragmented, and resurface in unsettling ways.

FAQ about Penpal

Is Penpal based on a true story?

No, Penpal is a work of fiction. However, the realistic and unsettling nature of the story has led some readers to believe it might be based on real events.

What is the significance of the title ‘Penpal’?

The title refers to the mysterious and unsettling figure from the narrator’s childhood who plays a central role in the story’s events and the unraveling of the mystery.

What are some of the key themes explored in the book?

Penpal explores themes of childhood trauma, memory, the uncanny, psychological horror, isolation, and the search for truth.

Is Penpal a scary book?

Penpal is widely considered a chilling and disturbing horror novel due to its atmospheric writing, psychological depth, and exploration of unsettling themes.

Penpal Quotes

  • “The past is never dead. It’s not even past.”
  • “Sometimes dead is better.”
  • “There are things known and there are things unknown, and in between are the doors of perception.”